Yankees Face $23.15 Million Decision on Closer David Bednar
· Latest NewsThe Yankees are approaching a pivotal moment in their offseason, and it centers on the future of their closer. By 4 p.m. Tuesday, the team will know whether David Bednar has accepted or rejected a one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer — a decision that will shape how the front office rebuilds a bullpen that needs serious attention.
If Bednar accepts, the Yankees fill one major hole at a record average annual value for a reliever. If he rejects it, the club will have to decide how aggressively to pursue him on the open market, where the price could climb even higher in total dollars even if the annual figure comes down.
A Record Offer and a Likely Rejection
The $23.15 million figure would set a new benchmark for reliever pay on a per-year basis. Even so, Bednar appears well positioned to surpass that total in a multiyear deal on the free agent market, albeit at a lower average annual value. That dynamic makes it seem likely he will turn down the qualifying offer.
Rejecting the offer would not close the door on a return to the Bronx. The Yankees can still re-sign Bednar after he declines, but they would then be bidding against other clubs rather than negotiating exclusively with their own closer.
Bednar holds considerable leverage in that scenario. Any team that signs him would forfeit draft pick compensation and international bonus pool money because of the qualifying offer attached to him. Even with that cost, the 32-year-old right-hander is arguably the top closer available on the market. Former Padres lefty setup man Adrian Morejon, who will also carry a qualifying offer, may be the top reliever overall.
Proven Under the Brightest Lights
Since arriving from his hometown Pirates, Bednar has spent a year and a half in pinstripes and demonstrated he can handle the pressure of pitching the ninth inning for the Yankees — something that is far from guaranteed, as Devin Williams showed recently. Across 86 appearances with the club, Bednar posted a 2.39 ERA with 45 saves.
That success carried into the postseason, where he allowed just one run over nine innings for the Yankees.
His impact extended beyond the stat line. Teammates and coaches praised Bednar for establishing a strong culture in the bullpen, helping the unit finish with the second-lowest ERA in the majors last season at 3.13 despite a lack of established options around him.
"He's a cool customer," general manager Brian Cashman said last week. "We've been very lucky over the course of time for the most part to have somebody with a strong presence and great leadership to lead out there, and he checked all those boxes along with the performance. So I've had some good additions, I've had some not-so-good additions. He's been a good addition so far, and hopefully we find a way to keep him so I can worry about surrounding him with more quality individuals that our manager can turn to late in the game to try to close things out."
Bullpen Rebuild Already Underway
The Yankees have started addressing their relief corps. They agreed to re-sign lefty Tim Hill on a one-year, $2.25 million deal with a $2.5 million club option for 2028. They are also very interested in bringing back Paul Blackburn at the right price after he became a key relief arm last season.
Bednar, of course, would cost far more. Cashman declined to say whether the Yankees and Bednar's camp were negotiating a multiyear pact before Tuesday's deadline, but the baseline for such a deal could be the three-year, $51 million contract Williams signed with the Mets last winter.
Cashman also said he is "not afraid" to spend big on a reliever, despite not having done so since 2019 with Zack Britton and Aroldis Chapman — deals that both ended poorly.
The two sizable reliever contracts completed so far this winter should only strengthen Bednar's case for a significant raise from the $9 million he earned in his final year of arbitration last season. Emilio Pagán signed with the Tigers for one year and $11.5 million, while Evan Phillips joined the Braves for three years and $35 million.
Fallback Options and Other Deadlines
Should Bednar land elsewhere, the Yankees could pursue Morejon, though he is expected to be even more expensive. They could also attempt to trade for a closer like Trevor Megill, who is coming off a World Series championship with the Brewers and entering the final year of team control.
Either way, the Yankees need multiple reinforcements. As of Monday, Hill and fellow lefty Brent Headrick were the only sure things for the 2027 unit, with setup man Fernando Cruz — a possible non-tender candidate by Friday's deadline — trying to prove he can pitch through a partially torn UCL. The club has been linked to former Yankee Jonathan Loáisiga, former Dodgers lefty Alex Vesia and former Cardinals/Brewers lefty JoJo Romero, among others.
Tuesday also marks the deadline to protect eligible players from the Rule 5 draft by adding them to the 40-man roster, even with no guarantee the draft will take place because of the impending lockout; it was not held during the last offseason with a lockout. The Yankees' most obvious candidate to add is hard-throwing right-hander Carlos Lagrange. Cashman said the club still views him as a starter, though they tried converting him to a reliever in the middle of last season at Triple-A, only for him to injure his shoulder and lose a chance to make his big league debut in 2026.
For the Yankees, Tuesday's qualifying offer decision is the first domino. Whether Bednar stays or goes will determine just how busy the rest of their winter becomes.